Spring 2000
POL 3441
Politics of Environmental Protection
T - Th 11:00 - 12:15
Mr. Holt
1209 Soc Sci 626-8626
Office Hours: T 10:00 - 10:30 & W 10:30 - 11:30
rholt@polisci.umn.edu

TA: Renee Wilson
1368 Soc Sci 624-4029
Ofice Hours: T, Th 12:30 - 2:00
rwilson@polisci.umn.edu

This course will cover four topics. The first is an introduction to environmental issues as political and public policy issues. The concern is on how to analyze and understand environmental issues. It takes neither an alarmist nor a complacent point of view. Rather it looks coolly and dispassionately at environmental issues and suggests how one may analyze them from a political perspective and how certain political systems may be expected to attempt to resolve them, and why. This part of the course will provide the basis for analyzing and understanding the politics of environmental protection in three different settings. Air pollution will be used as an example of an environmental problem and a brief introduction will be provided on some of the technical aspects of air pollution.

The second topic will deal with the environmental issue of clear air in the United States and will examine in some detail the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 - the major piece of environmental legislation passed in the United States over the past 15 years. You will learn something specifically about how American government and politics work in regard to environmental matters and something more generally about how presidential systems with non-disciplined parties are likely to deal with environmental issues.

The controversial issue of economic growth and environmental protection in developing countries will be the third topic discussed. Are economic growth and environmental protection compatible? If so, what kind of political-economic system is most likely to achieve this joint objective?

Some environmental issues are truly international issues and must be approached at an international level. The depletion of the ozone layer and possible global climate changes are examples. The final section of the course will deal with the Montreal Protocols which have restricted ozone depleting chemicals and will also consider the complex issue of global climate change.

Because in recent years international environmental issues have been intertwined with international trade matters, some treatment of this controversial issue will be included.

There will be two mid-term and one final examination. A paper of ten to fifteen pages on a topic of your choosing (which must be approved by the instructor) is due on 20 April. A one or two paragraph proposal suggesting a topic and how it will be approached is due by 27 January. It is highly desirable to submit this proposal by e-mail, and the instructor will e-mail an approval or suggestions for change immediately. For students who would like a review of a preliminary version of the paper, a draft must be submitted no later than 4 April.

The final examination and the paper will each make up one-third of your grade. Each mid-quarter will contribute one- sixth. Cheating or any other academic misconduct on an examination will lead to a zero grade on that examination. Plagiarism or any other academic misconduct on the required paper will lead to a zero grade on the paper. It is highly unlikely that a passing grade can be earned in this course if a zero is received on any examination or on the paper. The instructor will not consent to a withdrawal or an incomplete for any student who has engaged in academic misconduct.

While attendance is not taken nor required in this class, all students are responsible for all material presented in class, contained in the required reading, and contained in the paper submitted.


Required Textbooks: (all students)
    Richard Cohen, Washington at Work, Macmillan, New York 1992.

    Michael E. Kraft, Environmental Policy and Politics, HarperCollins, New York 1996.
On Reserve (Wilson Library)
    World Bank, World Development Report 1992: Development and the Environment, Chapters 2, 3, 4, and 9.

    The Economist,"Count Before You Leap", 7 July 1990 pp 21-24. (by William Nordhaus)
    "Reading the Patterns", 1 April, 1995

    Global Climate Change: Papers from Issues in Science and Technology, National Academy of Science.

    D. A. Bromley, "The Making of a Greenhouse Policy", Fall. 1990, pp. 55-61.

    R. E. Benedick, "Ozone Diplomacy", Fall 1989.

    D. D. Doniger, "Politics of the Ozone Layer", Spring 1988.

    J. T. Mathews, "Global Climate Change", Spring 1987, pp.57-68.

    W. Harrington, M. A. Walls, V. D. McConnell, "Using Economic Incentive to Reduce Auto Pollution," Winter, 1994-95.

    William D. Nordhaus, "Expert Opinion on Climatic Change" American Scientist vol 82, Jan.-Feb. 1994 pp. 45-51

    National Academy of Public Administration, The Environment Goes to Market, pp. 5-20.
    Wallace S. Broecker, "Chaotic Climate," Scientific American, November 1995, pp.62-68.

    The following four articles were all published in Science

    R. Wilson and E.A.C. Crouch, Risk Assessment and Comparisons, vol. 236, 17 April 1987, pp.267-270.
    L. B. Lave, Health and Safety Risk Analyses, vol. 236, 17 April 1987, pp.291-295.
    M. Russell and M. Gruber, Risk Assessment in Environmental Policy-Making, vol. 236, 17 April 1987, pp. 286-290.
    P. Slovic, Perception of Risk, vol. 236, 17 April 1987, pp. 280-284.


    Jonathan H. Adler, " Clean Fuels, Dirty Air", in Michael S. Greve and Fred L. Smith, Jr., Environmental Politics, pp. 19-46.

    Peter C. List, Radical Environmentalism, pp. 1-38; 47-55; 70-80.

    William Baumol and Wallace Oates, The Theory of Environmental Policy, pp. 16-35.

    Elinor Ostrum, Governing the Commons, pp. 1-30.

    Bruce Yandle, The Political Limits of Environmental Protection, p. 1-40.

    David W. Pearce and Jeremy Warfoord, World Without End, pp. 3-64;173-214.

    The following three articles were published in The Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 8. no. 4 (Fall 1994) pp. 3-63

    Paul. R. Portney, "The Contingent Valuation Debate," pp. 3- 18. W. Michael Hanemann, "Valuing the Environment through Contingent Valuation," pp. 19-44. Peter A. Diamond and Jerry A. Hausman, "Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number Better than No Number?"
    Science, "Greenhouse Report Foresees Growing Global Stress," Vol. 270, 3 November 1995, p. 731.
    Science, "The Terrestrial Carbon Cycle", vol 280, 29 May 1998 Richard A.Kerr, "Greenhouse Forecasting Still Cloudy" and John W.Zillman, Atmospheric Science and Public Policy,"
    Science, vol. 276. 16 May 1997, pp.1040-1042; 1084-1086.



    WEEKLY TOPICS AND READING ASSIGNMENTS

    1st Week

    One page proposal for term paper due on 27 January

    Part I BACKGROUND FOR ANALYSIS

    Study Questions For Part 1

    18, 20 January - Causes and consequences of air pollution (physical and biological sciences)

    Readings:
      Kraft, pp. 1-49;

      The Economist, "Reading the Patterns", 1 April, 1995
      Directions on how to access this article Online.

      Richard A.Kerr, "Greenhouse Forecasting Still Cloudy", Science v. 276 16 May 97, pp. 1040-1042.
      Availible Online

      John W.Zillman, Atmospheric Science and Public Policy," Science, vol. 276. 16 May 1997, pp.1084-1086.
      Availible Online

      William H. Calvin, "The Great Climate Flipflop", Atlantic Monthly, January 1998
      Availible Online

      Wallace S. Broecker, "Chaotic Climate," Scientific American, November 1995, pp.62-68.
    1. Acid rain
    2. Smog
    3. Ozone layer depletion
    4. Global climate warming
    5. Energy

    2nd Week

    25, 27 January - Causes and consequences of pollution (social sciences)

    Readings:
      William Baumol and Wallace Oates, The Theory of Environmental Policy, pp. 16-35.

      Bruce Yandle, The Political Limits of Environmental Protection, p. 1-40.

      David Pearce and Jeremy Warford, World without End, pp. 173-214.

      Harrington, et. al., "Using Economic Incentive to Reduce Auto Pollution".

      Peter C. List, Radical Environmentalism, pp. 1-38; 47-55; 70-80.

    1. Market failure
    2. Policy failure
    3. Institutional failure
    4. Environmental values and ethics

    3rd Week

    1, 3 February - Policy and Politics

    Readings:
      Paul R. Portney, "The Contingent Evaluation Debate" p. 3-18. W.

      Michael Hanemann, " Valuing the Environment through Contingent Valuation," pp. 19-43.

      Peter Diamond and Jerry A. Hausman, "Contingent Valuation: Is Some Number Better Than No Number? pp. 45-64.

      National Academy of Public Administration, "The Environment Goes to Market," pp. 5-20.

      V. Kerry Smith, Estimating Economic Values of Nature, pp.ix-55(Optional)

    1. Evaluating the Environment
    2. Types and choice of intervention instruments
    3. Types of policies

    4th Week

    8, 10 February - Policy and issues (Con't.)

    Readings:
      The following 4 articles are from Science, vol.236, 17 April 1987: Wilson and E.A.C. Crouch, Risk Assessment and Comparisons, pp.267-270. L. B. Lave, Health and Safety Risk Analyses, pp.291-295. M. Russell and M. Gruber, Risk Assessment in Environmental Policy-Making, pp. 286-290. P. Slovic, Perception of Risk, pp. 280-284.

    1. Risk assessment
    2. Public Opinion on environmental issues.

    5th Week

    15 February - Review for First Mid-term Examination

    17 February FIRST MID-QUARTER EXAMINATION


    6th Week

    Part II CLEAN AIR ACT AMENDMENTS 1990

    Study Questions For Part II

    22, 24 February

    Readings:
      Kraft, 50 - 118; Cohen, pp. 1 - 63

    1. The historical background
    2. Presidential politics and Presidential initiations

    7th Week

    29 February, 2 March

    Kraft, 119 - 156; Cohen, 64 - 180.

    1. The Congress
    2. Interest Groups

    8th Week

    7, 9 March

    Adler, " Clean Fuels, Dirty Air".

    1. The politics of acid rain
    2. The politics of urban smog
    3. Market failure and its statutory correction in the United States

    9th Week

    14 March, Second mid-term examination review

    16 March, Second mid-term examination

    10th Week

    Part III THE POLITICS OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ECONOMIC GROWTH

    Study Questions For Part III & IV

    21, 23 March

    Readings:
      World Bank, World Development Report 1992: Development and the Environment, Chapters 2, 3, 4, and 9.

    1. Inward oriented policies
    2. Outward oriented policies
    3. Economic performance
    4. Environmental record
    11th Week

    28, 30 March SPRING BREAK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    12th Week

    4, 6 April

    Readings: Pearce and Warford, pp. 3-64: 261-280.
    Global Biodiversity Scenarios for the Year 2001
    Article Availible Online

    Can Protected Areas Be Expanded in Africa?
    Article Availible Online

    Thomas L. Friedman: In networked world, activists can do more than say no
    Article Availible Online
    1. The politics of growth
    2. The politics of environmental protection
    3. Can developing countries both develop economically and protect the environment?

    4 April - Last day to submit drafts of paper for those who wish to have a review


    13th week
    PART IV The ozone layer and global climate warming

    Study Questions For Part III & IV

    Bromley, "The Making of a Greenhouse Policy", Fall. 1990.R. E. Benedick, "Ozone Diplomacy", Fall 1989. D. D. Doniger, "Politics of the Ozone Layer", Spring 1988. J. T. Mathews, "Global Climate Change", Spring 1987. Nordhouse, "Expert Opinion on Climatic Change," Nordhaus, "Count Before You Leap"

    1. CFC's and ozone depletion
    2. The Montreal Protocols

    11, 13 April
      Review these two articles available on the Web
      Richard A.Kerr, "Greenhouse Forecasting Still Cloudy", Science v. 276 16 May 97, pp1040-1042.
      Article Availible Online

      John W.Zillman, Atmospheric Science and Public Policy," Science, vol. 276. 16 May 1997, pp.1084-1086.
      Article Availible Online
      Also read the following:

      "The Kyoto Negotiations on Climate Change", Science, Vol 279, 16 January 1998, pp. 330;
      Article Availible Online

      "A Road Map for U.S. Carbon Reductions", Science, vol 279, 30 January 1998, pp. 669-670;
      Article Availible Online

      "Possibly Vast Greenhouse Gas sponge Ignites Controversy," Science, vol. 282, 16 October 1998;
      Article Availible Online

      "A Large Terrestial Carbon Sink in North America...", Science vol. 282 16 October 1998, pp. 442445.
      Article Availible Online

      "Acid Rain Control: Success on the Cheap," Science vol 282, 6 November 1998, pp.1024-1027;
      Article Availible Online

      "Fossil Fuels Without CO2 Emissions" Science, vol 282., 6 November 1998, pp. 1053-1054;
      Article Availible Online

    1. Global climate warming
    2. Kyoto

    14th Week

    18 April

    Bette Hileman, "Greenhouse Gas Economics", Chemical and Engineering News, 2 March 1998, pp. 31.
    1. Kyoto continued

    20 April TERM PAPERS DUE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Economist, " Why the Greens Should Love Trade" 9 October 1999, p. 17.

    (More readings will be assinged on this topic.)

    1. International trade and environmental protection

    15th Week

    25 April

    1. The Seattle Conference

    27 April

    Readings: Kraft, 157 - 207

    1. Assessing environmental policy

    16th Week

    2, 4 May

    1. Summary and review

    FINAL EXAM 1:30 - 3:30 pm, Tuesday 9 May 2000



SUMMER 2001

SPRING 2001

FALL 2000

SUMMER 2000

SPRING 2000

FALL 1999

SUMMER 1999

SPRING 1999

WINTER 1999

FALL 1998

SUMMER 1998

GRADUATE UNDERGRAD PEOPLE COURSES INFORMATION CONTACT